A utility company
is seeking to expand its natural gas distribution system to four
Cheshire County towns on, or abutting, the proposed Northeast Energy
Direct pipeline route.
And while some view
the move as an opportunity to boost the region’s economic development,
it’s not sitting well with those opposed to the pipeline.
“I really think this just gives
the pipeline another strong reason to come through unfortunately,”
Winchester Selectmen Chairman Roberta A. Fraser said. “We are opposed to
the pipeline. It’s not good news for us, but we’ll work with what we
have to do.”
Liberty Utilities, which is also
known in New Hampshire as EnergyNorth Natural Gas Inc., has submitted a
petition to the state Public Utilities Commission asking its members to
approve a gas franchise covering Jaffrey, Rindge, Swanzey and
Winchester.
The approval is needed for
Liberty Utilities to build, own and operate natural gas distribution
systems in those towns, which now don’t have access to such systems.
Move keeps options open
Liberty Utilities plans to tap
into the Northeast Energy Direct pipeline to provide natural gas to the
four towns. But company officials say in the petition that they’re
requesting the natural gas franchise rights for the communities
regardless if the pipeline is built.
Liberty Utilities filed the Oct. 9
petition about a week after the Public Utilities Commission approved an
agreement between Liberty Utilities and the Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co.
allowing Liberty to buy natural gas off the proposed Northeast Energy
Direct pipeline.
William J. Clark, a business
development professional for Liberty Utilities, referenced the decision
in testimony to the state commission, saying that the plan is to supply
the four towns with natural gas from the pipeline.
However, Liberty Utilities would
look at the options of serving communities with liquefied natural gas
(LNG) and compressed natural gas (CNG), if the pipeline is delayed or
not built, he said.
Liberty Utilities has 1,250
customers in Keene connected to a propane-air mixture distribution
system, according to its petition.
If the pipeline isn’t approved,
company officials would analyze converting that Keene system to
liquefied or compressed natural gas and extending it south to Swanzey
and Winchester, Clark said.
Liberty Utilities “would also evaluate the possibility of serving Rindge and Jaffrey with LNG and CNG,” he said.
Signs of a Keene lateral
Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co. LLC, a
Kinder Morgan company, is proposing the 30-inch diameter transmission
pipeline, which would carry natural gas from shale gas fields in
Pennsylvania through upstate New York, parts of northern Massachusetts
and into southern New Hampshire before going to a distribution hub in
eastern Massachusetts.
The pipeline’s proposed route has
it crossing about 70 miles of southern New Hampshire, including
Fitzwilliam, Richmond, Rindge, Troy and Winchester, and carrying up to
2.2 billion cubic feet per day of natural gas. The amount is equivalent
to providing electricity for 1.5 million households.
The pipeline is still in the
pre-filing stages with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which
has the power to approve or deny the project. Tennessee Gas Pipeline
officials plan to file the full application for the project with FERC
this fall. Company officials anticipate it will take a year for the
pipeline to receive federal approval, if it does.
In its Oct. 9 petition, Liberty
Utilities’ officials wrote that Jaffrey, Rindge, Swanzey and Winchester
have a total of about 8,530 single- and multi-family homes. There are
also commercial centers along the state highways in those towns, the
petition said.
“By approving this Petition, the
Commission will be creating opportunities for economic development and
cost savings for both existing and new commercial and residential
customers in these towns,” company officials wrote in the petition.
Liberty Utilities is a subsidiary
of Algonquin Power and Utilities Corp, a company that has its
headquarters in Canada and is participating in the development of the
Northeast Energy Direct pipeline with Kinder Morgan.
In his testimony, Clark said the
route of the distribution system for Swanzey and Winchester would start
in Winchester, where Liberty Utilities’ line would connect to the
Northeast Energy Direct pipeline. The system would then extend north
into Swanzey and connect to Liberty Utilities’ distribution system in
Keene.
That would be done by extending
gas mains along Routes 10 and 12 from the Keene system, which would be
converted from its current propane-air mixture to natural gas at the
same time as the expansion is being done, Clark said.
What Clark described matches what
Liberty Utilities’ officials have proposed as the Keene Lateral, a line
that would branch off the Northeast Energy Direct pipeline to provide
natural gas to Liberty Utilities’ customers in Keene.
Liberty Utilities’ officials were unavailable for comment by press time this morning.
Out of loop
Included with Clark’s testimony
were maps of the proposed route Liberty Utilities’ natural gas
distribution systems would follow in each town (see related sidebar), as
well as estimated expansion costs.
The Winchester project’s estimated cost is $1.3 million.
Richard Horton, chairman of the
Winchester School Board, said Liberty Utilities filing the petition for a
gas franchise is “purely a way to show there is some sort of need for
it.
“I can tell you from the school’s
aspect, we don’t have a need for natural gas. We have a need for
conserving energy, but not a need or desire for natural gas,” he said.
The school board has publicly taken a stance against the Northeast Energy Direct pipeline.
Horton added that the filing so
soon after the N.H. Public Utilities Commission approved the agreement
between Liberty Utilities and Tennessee Gas Pipeline — and with no
notice to residents in the affected communities — is pretty consistent
with how things have been happening recently with the pipeline.
Swanzey selectmen learned at
Tuesday’s board meeting of Liberty Utilities’ proposal, and that company
officials want to schedule public presentations in each of the four
towns included in the requested gas franchise.
Selectmen Chairman Deborah J.
Davis said Wednesday she hadn’t given the proposal much thought since
the meeting. But board members plan to schedule Liberty Utilities for a
presentation to residents, business owners and town officials.
“It has potential, maybe, but I think it’s too early to tell,” she said. “We’d have to find out more specifics.”
Liberty Utilities’ officials
estimate the Swanzey expansion could cost $990,146 along Route 10, and
about $1.1 million along Route 12.
Rindge Selectmen Chairman Robert
Hamilton described Liberty Utilities’ proposal to expand natural gas
service into Jaffrey, Rindge, Swanzey and Winchester as a “deflection of
the NED pipeline.”
“I’ve read over the petition, and I have a multitude of questions,” he said.
Two, he said, are whether the
town has any say in the franchise agreement, and whether Liberty
Utilities is willing to dedicate its funds to providing natural gas for
the entire town.
“It’s a very minuscule area of town they would be providing gas to,” he said.
Proposed natural gas distribution routes
Liberty Utilities
submitted the following proposed routes in its petition to the N.H.
Public Utilities Commission to expand natural gas service to Jaffrey,
Rindge, Swanzey and Winchester.
In Winchester, the
system could provide natural gas to Applewood Rehabilitation Center on
Snow Road, as well as homes and businesses along Warwick Road (Route 78)
from where it intersects with Manning Hill Road (Route 10) and General
James Reed Highway (Route 119) southeast to just past Snow Road. The
system could also extend to properties along Route 10 between the
intersections of Routes 78 and 119, and Main Street (Route 10) and
Richmond Road (Route 119).
The distribution system could
then continue along Richmond Road, ending in the area of Plumb Pak Corp.
There would also be a branch line off Main Street at Parker Street that
would follow the road to the Winchester School, which enrolls students
in preschool through 8th grade.
Two lines could be run through
the neighborhood near the school, connecting the Parker Street and
Richmond Road pipelines, according to the map.
Swanzey would stand to get
natural gas service along West Swanzey Road (Route 10) in the town’s
west village, and Monadnock Highway (Route 12) in the community’s north
section.
The maps submitted to the Public
Utilities Commission show the line along Route 12 traveling southeast
from Keene past the Lake Street and Swanzey Factory Road intersection,
stopping just before the Cheshire Fairgrounds and Safford Drive.
The map from West Swanzey shows
only the natural gas line traveling along South Winchester Street to
just over the town line, stopping at Market Basket.
In Rindge and Jaffrey, company
officials propose distributing natural gas along Routes 119 and 202. The
expansion project for those communities would be done in two phases,
with the first estimated to cost $2.1 million and the second projected
at $2 million.
According to the maps, the
distribution system could run from where it connects with the Northeast
Energy Direct pipeline north to the intersection of Routes 119 and 202
before continuing up Route 202 to Jaffrey.
At the intersection, the system could also travel west along Route 119 ending at Franklin Pierce University.
Meghan Foley can be reached at 352-1234, extension 1436, or mfoley@keenesentinel.com. Follow her on Twitter @MFoleyKS.
